weight empowerment
I have been following the Tyra Banks People magazine/weight-freak-out with mild interest for a while. I saw the video clip on YouTube and told everyone I knew about it, well, everyone close to me. I got a myriad of responses about it; applause to her, criticizing her, everything. This morning, she put her lanky butt in that red bodysuit (she wore it on a different People mag. cover), dressed everyone in the audience in the same body suit, and had all the women put their body weight on the front. The result was an attempt to create a powerful image of empowered women, flaunting their scale number with disregard. A visual “So what?!?!” in Tyra terms. All these women were supposed to walk away from that show feeling like they aren’t defined by their scale, their weight does not determine their worthiness. It’s a strong and responsible message promoted by a woman who had previously broke boundaries and stereotypes when she became a model. In a dramatic slap in the face to major media, she had the women peel their numbers from their chests, smash them up and throw them away, telling them they are not defined by those numbers. Slightly before I threw down the t-shirt I was meticulously folding to join in this weight anarchy, reality set in.
It’s a hard diet pill to swallow when I am trying to decide is Tyra is wearing the low, medium or super-high body slimming, fat smoothing suit under that red ensemble. Just what kind of shimmer powder did use down the front of her legs to lengthen and define, and what happened to the cellulite that was so prevalent on the first People magazine cover that set off this rampage? How many hours did she sit in the makeup chair getting her hair done and false eyelashes applied? Does she feel she is an accurate representation of a real woman? While I am all for a weight empowerment movement, how about having a recovering anorexic on the show? Considering you never pull yourself completely out of the self-destructive, overly critical mind frame, any anorexic will do. Or a bulimic. Or how about that all-encompassing disorder EDNOS - eating disorder not otherwise specified - which includes binge eaters and people who sway violently throw multiple disorders. In light of dying models, starving themselves for the catwalk, this is a positive message. Until you remember the village-raising-a-child lesson. I’m all for Tyra parading healthy women on stage, telling stories of life-change Tyra experiences, hell Tyra, we applaud you already. But until majority of media, majority of society promotes a healthy body image, we aren’t going anywhere. All she is doing is stroking her own ego. Telling herself that 161 is her healthy body weight, then asking others to validate her conclusion. I’m not doubting her, she looks healthy. But you can’t have one show on weight empowerment and expect the issue to be resolved. Eating disorders and societal beliefs don’t change overnight AND they go hand in hand. I wake up in the morning thinking I’m a healthy weight. And just as easily as I make that decision, I make the decision that I haven’t reached that elusive “good enough” stage. You need individual and societal re-wiring. Just like a single woman alone didn’t start and end the women’s movement, she enlisted assistance, appealed to people common sense and human decency to start a movement, or multiple people working together towards a common liberating goal. It drives me crazy that someone, be it Tyra or someone else, can climb on stage after being called fat and demand restitution. After spending her entire life being praise for her svelte figure and good genes, she deserves an apology? Um, no. That girl who starved herself to death deserves the apology. Women and men in mental institutions trying to correct their horrible misconceptions on the perfect body deserve an apology. The 8-year-old girl who thinks she fat and doesn’t want lunch deserves an apology, along with her mom, the constant dieter. Tyra deserves a head tip in acknowledgement. Applaud the people who have been through the looking glass of society’s weight persecution and, in their own way, shape and form, try to make it back to healthy. I stumble, fall and regress. We all do.
You get no sympathy.